The position
Depth beats coverage.
Most of your logins do not matter much. A forum, a shop, a newsletter, losing them costs an afternoon.
A few do matter: the email everything recovers through, the bank, the phone account, the recovery codes. If those go, the rest goes with them.
Keep the short list on a card and use whatever you like for the long tail. The two are not competing.
The short list
What earns a place.
- Primary email
- Because everything else resets through it.
- Phone account
- Because a number is a key in disguise.
- Bank
- Because recovery there is slow and human.
- Recovery codes
- Because they exist precisely for the bad day.
- Master password
- Because it opens the long tail.
A short list,
kept properly.